Search
Pale coastal condominium buildings rise behind palms and lush landscaping beside a calm blue-green lake in soft morning light.

How to Read Pelican Bay's Price Numbers This Fall

November 19, 2026

The most expensive home sold in Collier County in August 2026 was 7613 Bay Colony Drive in Pelican Bay. It listed at $21,000,000, sold at $21,000,000 and recorded zero days on market, according to the Naples Daily News. The 12,505-square-foot Gulf-front home was built in 2000. A sale like that tells you a great deal about one house and one buyer. It tells you very little about what a Pelican Bay condo or villa is worth this week.

That gap between one transaction and the market is the most useful thing to keep in mind as season arrives. In a small, high-priced corner of Naples, a monthly median reflects which homes happened to close that month. The figure that holds steady from one report to the next, and the one that shapes a buyer's winter, is how much is for sale.

September's Headline Numbers Point in Opposite Directions

The Naples Area Board of Realtors groups Pelican Bay's ZIP code, 34108, with 34102 and 34103 in an area it calls Naples Beach. Its September 2026 report was released October 23 and is current through October 10. It is the latest NABOR report available when this post publishes. Read at face value, the report says single-family homes in the beach ZIPs jumped in price and condos fell sharply, all in the same month.

Naples Beach area, Sept. 2026 vs. Sept. 2025 Single-family Condo
September median closed price $2,764,500, up 49.4% $887,500, down 24.1%
September average closed price $6,604,682, up 72.2% $1,483,526, down 7.4%
Year-to-date median, through September $2,900,000, down 3.3% $1,052,500, down 7.3%
September closed sales 44, up 18.9% 64, up 10.3%
Homes for sale at month's end 367, down 23.5% 564, down 21.3%
Months of supply 7.3, down from 11.7 6.4, down from 10.5
Percent of list price received, September 92.8% 92.9%

A real 24% drop in condo values would normally come with buyers stepping back and listings piling up. September showed the reverse. Condo sales rose 10.3% from September 2025, the number of condos for sale fell 21.3%, and sellers received a slightly higher share of their asking price than a year earlier. Prices that collapse while supply shrinks and buyers return don't make sense as a change in value. They make sense as a change in which condos sold.

The Median Measures the Mix

A median is the middle sale. In a month with 64 condo closings across three ZIP codes, the middle sale depends heavily on whether that month happened to bring more lower-priced units or more higher-priced ones. NABOR's own footnote says so plainly: percent changes "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size."

The condo average fell 7.4%, a third of the median's decline, so the higher-priced sales that month did not disappear. The year-to-date median, built on 870 condo sales through September instead of 64, is down 7.3%. A drift of a few percent across nine months is the more believable description of beach-area condo pricing in 2026. The 24% figure describes one month's mix of closings.

The single-family side works the same way in the opposite direction. A 49.4% jump in the September median and a 72.2% jump in the average came on 44 sales. Across the 469 single-family sales so far this year, the median is $2.9 million, 3.3% below the same stretch of 2025. In a market where a single Bay Colony estate can close at $21 million, a few large closings in one month are enough to move both numbers.

The ZIP-level table shows how much small samples swing the result. In September 2026, the 34102 median rose 92.5% to $3,450,000 on 23 sales. Next door in 34103, the median fell 36.3% to $1,012,500 on 28 sales. Each of those medians rested on a few dozen closings.

Pelican Bay's ZIP Shows the Steadier Signal

ZIP 34108 is the closest public measure to Pelican Bay, though it is not Pelican Bay alone. Naples Park shares the ZIP, for one. In September 2026, 34108's median closed price was $1,250,000, up 6.8% from September 2025, on 57 sales, up 35.7%. The 6.8% is a modest move, and it rests on the same kind of small, mixed sample as the swings above.

The inventory figure is the one to watch. At the end of September 2026, 300 properties were for sale in 34108, against 446 a year earlier, a drop of 32.7%. The average time on market was 121 days, nearly unchanged from 119. Across the broader beach area, months of supply fell from 11.7 to 7.3 for single-family homes and from 10.5 to 6.4 for condos over the same twelve months. Unlike the medians, these numbers all point the same way, in every segment and every month you check. A buyer arriving for season this year will choose from roughly a third fewer homes than a buyer who arrived last fall.

The countywide price-range table adds one exception that matters in Pelican Bay. For the overall Naples market, Collier County excluding Marco Island, months of supply for condos priced between $1.5 million and $5 million fell 53% year over year in September, from 11.7 to 5.5. For condos above $5 million, the only bracket where supply grew, it rose 10.6%, from 13.2 to 14.6 months. These are county figures, not Pelican Bay's. For a condo buyer in Pelican Bay, they mean the price bracket shapes how much choice there is, since supply is tightening below $5 million and not above it.

Less to Choose From, Without Higher Prices Yet

Fewer listings would usually mean rising prices. The people closest to the data are not calling that yet. In the Naples Area Board of Realtors' September release, Cindy Carroll said, "We are tight on inventory in so many zones across Collier, but I'm not seeing values go up yet." Mike Hughes put it this way: "Heading into season we may have less inventory, but the market is more balanced than a year ago." He added, "It has been a good year for the luxury market."

The same release reported that countywide pending sales fell 6.8% in September, to 702 from 753 a year earlier. Fewer homes are for sale, but there is no rush of new contracts to compete for them. That fits Carroll's read. Hughes also said the area is "seeing a lot of cash deals, but not because there are more cash buyers. It is because we have fewer buyers financing home purchases."

The beach-area table carries the practical detail for anyone making an offer. In September 2026, single-family sellers in the Naples Beach area received 92.8% of list price and condo sellers received 92.9%, both up from a year earlier. Sellers are giving up less than they were in 2025, but the typical closing in the beach ZIPs still lands about 7% below the asking price. Sherry Stein said in the NABOR release, "Sellers who are positioned correctly, with homes priced right, are selling quickly." Taken together, the numbers and the quotes describe a market where a well-priced listing moves fast, an overpriced one waits, and the gap between list and sale still leaves room to negotiate.

For a buyer weighing Pelican Bay against Park Shore or the Moorings, the September medians cannot rank these neighborhoods against each other. They are too thin and too dependent on mix. A comparison that holds up looks at individual buildings and enclaves: what a specific floor plan in a specific tower closed for recently, how long comparable units sat, and how many direct competitors are listed right now. Inside Pelican Bay, as the beach-area numbers show, the mix of buildings that close in a given month can move the median by itself.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Pelican Bay condo prices fall 24% this fall? No public figure shows that. The 24.1% decline was the September 2026 condo median for the whole Naples Beach area, three ZIP codes, on 64 sales. The year-to-date condo median for the same area through September was down 7.3%.

Is ZIP 34108 the same as Pelican Bay? No. Pelican Bay sits inside 34108, but the ZIP also includes other neighborhoods, such as Naples Park, so its figures blend Pelican Bay's market with theirs.

When will newer numbers be out? NABOR's release calendar lists November 20, 2026, as its next report date, which would cover October activity.

If you're comparing Pelican Bay buildings this season, Kaleena Figaro Group would be glad to talk through what this fall's supply numbers mean for the specific towers and enclaves on your list. Start Your Naples Home Search with us.

Follow Us On Instagram